Breaking News: Court Rules Against Freelancer Protections

December 1, 2007 by Tom Colvin
Filed under: 04-Submissions, Pricing & Billing, Uncategorized

Hello there! If you are new here, you might want to subscribe to the RSS feed for updates on this topic.

In a landmark decision, a US Court of Appeals struck down an agreement between freelancers and publishers regarding payment for reproducing articles in online editions. One part of the decision seems particularly chilling for free-lancers;

Judge Chester J. Straub wrote that federal copyright law allows claims for damages only by writers who have registered their work with the United States Copyright Office. The vast majority of freelancers did not register, so he said the courts had no jurisdiction over their disputes, and the case should not have been approved as a class-action suit.

To my unlawyerly mind, this means that writers must officially copyright every single word they write in order to receive protection. This ruling may open the door to rampant theft of writer’s work.

Thanks to Michael Downend for flashing this news along to me.Â Unfortunately, the link to this article doesn’t work here, as the New York Times protects its website with registration requirements.Â Ironic, is it not?

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

Tags:

Comments

211Comments2007-11-30+19%3A19%3A32Tom+Colvin on Breaking News: Court Rules Against Freelancer Protections

Jeremy Osborne on Sat, 1st Dec 2007 2:48 am

Hi Tom,

It appears the link to the article is broken. I tried to find it in a search but couldn’t. I wanted to read the article myself and then read the court report (if it was linked) before making any decisions about this.

Help from my friends and random people on IE8 Dynamic CSS?

To my five fans (to those reading that aren’t part of the fan 5 crew, my 5 fans are also good friends):
I have a bit of a dilemma in some web coding.
Problem: I need to be able to dynamically in[...]

Jeanne Dininni on Sat, 1st Dec 2007 3:21 am

Tom,

The worst part about this is that, for years, writers have been lulled into a false sense of security by being told that their works were copyrighted the moment they created them–regardless of whether or not they decided to register them with the U.S. Copyright Office. Looks as if we’re now beginning to see the limitations of such “natural” copyrights!

Thanks for this important info!
Jeanne

Tom Colvin on Sat, 1st Dec 2007 8:49 am

Jeremy, sorry about the broken link. I’ve revised my post accordingly — with a note of irony.

Tom

Freelance Writing Jobs - The Internet’s #1 Freelance Writer Community » Blog Archive » Weekend Link Love for December 1st, 2007 on Sat, 1st Dec 2007 10:40 pm

[...] Breaking News: Court Rules Against Freelance Protection at Becoming a Writer Seriously. [...]

Scott on Sun, 2nd Dec 2007 2:18 am

I am wondering how this will affect Canadian writer’s.
I will have to look into this and our laws, but will this prove to be the same issue for Canadian copyrights?

Tom Colvin on Sun, 2nd Dec 2007 4:16 am

I finally found another posting about this decision at respected CNET:

http://www.news.com/Court-voids-deal-to-pay-freelancers-for-work-sent-to-Web/2100-1030_3-6220850.html
And here’s some history from earlier on in the case:

http://freelancerights.blogspot.com/2007_03_01_archive.html

I have absolutely no idea how this ruling will impact Canadian writers, nor even where it goes from here for US freelancers.

In the process, I’ve just realized that my Comments Box is not “url friendly.” Does anyone know a Word Press comment plug-in that works better than this, preferably allowing a link, or at the very least wrapping the url text?

Tom

Tom Colvin on Wed, 5th Dec 2007 8:13 pm

Writers Digest editor Maria Schneider in her blog The Writer’s Perspective wrote yesterday about the copyright decision, with some useful detail and a couple of additional links. She points out that it costs $45 per copyright. Multiply that by every article we write? Articles that might not earn much more than $45 in the first place? This ruling may be very serious indeed for freelancers! You can find her post at:

http://www.writersdigest.com/writersperspective/Is Copyright Now Necessary .aspx

FOUR CORNERSTONES of PRODUCTIVITY 4 WRITERS

After more than two years of blogging, I've come to realize that there are four areas writers must address to improve their productivity: Thinking, Organizing, Writing, Promoting. Below are some of the best books to help you master these challenges.
1 - THINKING
.....
2 - ORGANIZING
.....
3 - WRITING
.....
4 - PROMOTING
..... VIDEO FOR WRITERS here offers only four out of a large collection of video useful to writers. To see an annotated list of all of them, just click on the title of the box below. .....
see all videos
________________
Add this to your site